Leadership

Culture Change Starts With the People Who Report to You

· 5 min read

Leaders who want a different culture usually start by talking to everyone. The people in the unit learn what is actually expected by watching the five or six people closest to the leader, and nothing changes for them until that small group changes first.

Think about the last time you set out to change how your unit works. You probably started with the whole group. There was a meeting where you described what you wanted to see more of, maybe a written statement of values, maybe a retreat or a set of workshops. You were clear and you meant it, and for a few weeks people repeated some of your language back to you.

Then think about what happened the first time two of your direct reports disagreed in front of their own teams. Perhaps one of them went around the other to get a decision. Perhaps a concern raised in your leadership meeting was dismissed with a look that everyone at the table noticed. Perhaps a member of your senior group missed a commitment and nobody mentioned it. Those moments did more to settle what your unit believes than anything you said in the meeting with everyone, because the people in your unit were watching them closely and drawing conclusions from them.

People learn the rules from the group closest to you

Most people in a unit do not see the leader very often. They see their own supervisor, and they hear about how the leadership group operates through what their supervisor says and does after those meetings. When you announce a value, they take it as a statement of intent. When they watch how the people who report to you treat each other, they take it as evidence of what is rewarded.

This matters most in disagreement. Any group can be collegial when everyone wants the same thing. The real lesson is in what happens when two leaders want different things. If the disagreement gets settled by whoever has the stronger relationship with you, people learn that relationships decide. If it gets settled in a side conversation and announced as if it had always been the plan, people learn that open disagreement is not how things get done here. If one leader quietly stops cooperating with another after losing an argument, everyone working under both of them learns to protect their own group first.

None of this requires anyone to behave badly. Most leadership groups are made up of capable people trying to do their jobs. The difficulty is that they are being watched far more closely than they realize, and their ordinary habits with each other are being read as the actual policy.

What it costs to start with everyone

Your announcement gets measured against your leadership group, and it loses. When what you say in public and what people see in your senior group point in different directions, people believe what they see. They do not usually conclude that you were insincere. They conclude that the value is something leadership talks about and does not practice, which is worse, because it teaches them that values statements in general are not meant to be acted on.

Your direct reports become the people blocking a change they were never asked to make. If you go to the whole unit first, the people who report to you hear the new expectations at the same moment as everyone else. They had no chance to work out what it means for how they run their own groups or how they deal with each other. When their behavior does not shift, their teams read it as resistance, and sometimes it becomes resistance, because nobody likes being held to a standard they learned about in the same meeting as their staff.

You lose the people most willing to change. In every unit there are people who take a new direction seriously and start acting on it right away. They raise the concern openly, share the information, or push back in the meeting the way you said you wanted. If their own supervisor does not respond the way you described, they learn that acting on the stated culture carries a cost. They are usually the first to stop trying, and the people watching them take note.

Three moves

Start with your own leadership meeting. Before you say anything to the whole unit, describe the change to the people who report to you and ask a specific question: what would this look like in how we work with each other? Then agree on two or three concrete things. How you will handle a disagreement between two of your groups. What happens when one of you misses a commitment to another. Whether decisions made in this meeting get reopened privately afterward. Give it a month of practice before you take it wider.

Settle one real disagreement in the open. Wait for a genuine conflict between two of your direct reports, one that matters to both of their groups, and resolve it the way you want disagreements resolved across the unit. State the question, hear both positions in the same room, make the decision or name who will, and say why. Then make sure both leaders carry the same account of it back to their teams. One visible example of a disagreement handled well will travel further than a statement about how disagreements should be handled.

Ask your direct reports what their teams saw. Every few weeks, ask the people who report to you what their own staff noticed about how the leadership group operated recently. Not whether the change is working, which invites a polite answer, but what people observed. You will hear about moments you did not realize were visible. You will also give your direct reports a reason to pay attention to the same thing, which is the point.

The part that is about you

Your leadership group takes its cues from you in exactly the way your unit takes its cues from them. If you let one direct report go around another without comment, or settle a dispute in a private conversation because it is faster, the group learns that from you. The change you are asking for has to show up first in how you treat the people closest to you, including the ones you find harder to work with.

This also means accepting that culture change is slower than an announcement suggests. A group of five or six people can change how it works in a few months. Everyone else will need to see it last through several difficult weeks before they believe it is real. That slower path is still faster than the alternative, which is an announcement that people politely wait out.

Three questions

If someone three levels below you described how your leadership group handles disagreement, what would they say, and how would they know?

What was the last disagreement between two of your direct reports, and how did their teams find out how it was settled?

Is there a value you have announced to the whole unit that the people who report to you have never discussed as a group?